The charming front façade sets the tone, with white stucco, black-framed windows, a welcoming covered porch and a generous private driveway framed by mature landscaping. Inside, the original home retains the details that give older houses their soul: warm hardwood floors, substantial millwork, traditional doors, graceful transitions between rooms and inviting fireplaces. These character elements are complemented by a renovation that introduces clean lines, natural materials and a fresh, timeless palette throughout.

At the heart of the home is a spectacular kitchen designed for gathering. Custom cabinetry in soft, natural tones is paired with dramatic stone surfaces, premium appliances and a substantial centre island that provides an effortless place for everything from weekday breakfasts to evening entertaining. An abundance of cabinetry and thoughtfully integrated storage keeps the space as functional as it is beautiful.

The rear addition transforms the way the home lives. Expansive black-framed windows and oversized glass doors draw the outdoors in, filling the principal living spaces with natural light and creating a seamless connection to the backyard. The result is an open, airy environment with room to cook, dine, entertain and unwind while maintaining the warmth and intimacy of a traditional home.

Practicality has been considered just as carefully. A dedicated side-entry mudroom offers built-in seating, storage and hooks, while a stylish main-floor powder room brings personality with patterned wallcovering, a marble-topped vanity and statement details. Another standout feature of the main floor is the arched way butler’s nook off the kitchen, with additional counter space, custom cabinetry and specialized storage for effortless organization and entertaining.

Upstairs, the bedrooms are bright, comfortable and beautifully finished with hardwood flooring and excellent storage. One of the secondary bedrooms offers a particularly charming retreat with a vaulted ceiling, treetop views and space for both sleeping and study. The family bathroom continues the home’s thoughtful design with painted millwork, vertical panelling, a tub/shower and a playful checkerboard floor.

The primary suite is a destination unto itself. Generously proportioned and overlooking the surrounding greenery, it features a substantial custom walk-in dressing room and an exceptional spa-inspired ensuite. A long double vanity with natural wood cabinetry and dramatic stone counters is complemented by a freestanding soaker tub and an oversized glass shower wrapped in striking stone-look slabs, complete with rain and handheld fixtures. It is luxurious without feeling overstated.

The finished lower level adds another dimension to the home, offering exceptional flexibility for family life. A large recreation and media area provides space for movie nights and casual entertaining, while a dedicated fitness area makes working out at home easy. An additional bedroom and beautifully finished full bathroom create comfortable accommodations for guests, teenagers or extended family. There is also a dedicated laundry area with saloon doors, cabinetry and a sink, along with excellent storage, including a charming wine/storage room.

The backyard feels like a private retreat. Multiple walkouts from the rear of the home open onto an expansive wood deck with distinct areas for outdoor dining, lounging and barbecuing. Beyond the deck is a lawn framed by mature trees, established landscaping and natural stone.

A dedicated gravel fire-pit area creates another inviting gathering place, while the garden shed adds useful storage and character. The fully fenced setting provides privacy and room for children, pets, entertaining or simply enjoying a quiet afternoon beneath the trees. From summer dinners on the deck to evenings around the fire, the outdoor space feels like a natural extension of the home.

One of the greatest advantages of 304 Court Street is its setting. Here, you get the character and mature landscaping of an established Newmarket neighbourhood while remaining remarkably close to the heart of town.

Historic Main Street is nearby, placing local restaurants, cafés, boutiques and everyday conveniences within easy reach. The area offers a wonderful balance between small-town charm and the amenities expected of a thriving modern community.

Outdoor recreation is equally accessible. Fairy Lake, the Tom Taylor Trail and Newmarket Riverwalk Commons provide opportunities for walking, cycling, skating, community events and time outdoors throughout the seasons. The surrounding mature tree canopy reinforces the neighbourhood’s established feel and creates a setting increasingly difficult to replicate in newer communities.

Families will appreciate convenient access to schools, parks and recreational facilities, while Southlake Regional Health Centre and a wide variety of shopping and services are also close at hand. Newmarket GO Station, public transit and major commuter routes provide connections throughout York Region and into Toronto.

What makes this location particularly appealing, however, is the lifestyle it offers: leafy residential streets, distinctive homes, established gardens and a genuine sense of community, all within minutes of Newmarket’s historic downtown.

304 Court Street is more than a beautifully renovated house. It is the rare combination of character, modern craftsmanship, generous family space and an exceptional backyard, all in a neighbourhood where the best of Newmarket is close to home.

Possession | TBA
Property Taxes | $4,089.75 / 2026
Size | 2,203 sq ft. + 906 sq ft. below grade (as per floorplans)
Lot Size | 39.27 ft. x 119.95 ft.
Parking | Private drive 5 parking spots
Inclusions | Fridge, stove, range hood, dishwasher. Washer and dryer. All electric light fixtures and window coverings.
Exclusions | Horse bell on deck fence, all artwork, Tv’s and brackets, powder room mirror.
Other | Click here to view features & upgrades